BUY & SELL

Your Sports, Our Stock

At New to Me Sports, we’re passionate about fueling your love for the game with a diverse selection of gear for a variety of sports. Whether you’re lacing up for hockey, hitting the soccer field, swinging for the fences in baseball, or carving down the slopes, we’ve got you covered. Our inventory spans from popular team sports to specialized activities, ensuring you have the right equipment to elevate your performance. Explore our extensive range and gear up to play your best!

BaseBall

Disc Golf

Football

Golf

Hockey

LAcrosse

Raquet Sports

SKATES

SNOW SPORTS

Soccer

BaseBall

Disc Golf

Football

Golf

Hockey

Lacrosse

Raquet Sports

Skates

Snow Sports

Soccer

HOW IT WORKS

BRING IT IN

Drop off your quality sports equipment anytime, no appointment necessary.

WE INSPECT IT

Our friendly knowledgeable staff will assess your items based on condition and demand while you explore our store.

GET PAID!

We’ll negotiate a price that works for you. Receive cash on the spot or get even more with Store Credit. 

Common Questions

At New to Me Sports, we assess the value of your equipment based on factors like brand, condition, and current demand. Typically, we resell pre-owned items at 40-60% of their new retail price. When you sell to us, you can expect to receive 30-50% of this resale value, influenced by the item’s specifics and our inventory levels.

We offer two compensation options:

  • Store Credit Bonus: Opt for store credit and receive an additional 10-20% over the cash offer, providing greater value for Trade In. Trade up
  • Cash Payment: Choose to receive cash for your gear.

We purchase used equipment year-round. Bringing in items just before or during their active season can yield a higher value, as demand peaks during these times. This approach ensures you receive the most competitive offer for your gear.

Any time during business hours, no appointment needed!

Monday – Friday: 10 am – 8 pm
Saturday: 10 am – 6 pm
Sunday: 11 am – 6 pm

We offer a diverse selection of both pre-owned and new sports equipment. Our new items complement our inventory, ensuring we meet the needs of customers seeking brand-new gear at competitive prices. We’re continually seeking quality used sports and fitness equipment. Bring in your gear today, and we’ll provide you with a fair offer.

New To Me Sports will accept returns of new merchandise accompanied by the original receipt within 30 days of purchase, provided the item is unopened and in as-new, resalable condition. We will issue a refund for the purchase price in the original form of payment.

New To Me Sports will accept returns of used merchandise accompanied by receipt within 7 days of purchase. We will issue a refund for the purchase price in the form of store credit.

Final sale items and Store Credits are non-returnable and non-refundable.

Get in touch and let us know how we can help!

Name(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get in touch and let us know how we can help!

Name(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.